The only question I didn't get to in the December posting meme (I think) was
aragarna, who asked,
What's special about White Collar?... which is not entirely an easy question to answer. I don't know
why, exactly, I've latched onto this show so hard. There are better shows out there; there are certainly shows whose plots make more sense. To some extent it's the same indescribable something that makes a person either fall in love with a book, or give up halfway through -- some stories and some characters you just
like, and some you don't.
The closest I can come to pinning down the appeal of White Collar to me is that it gives me relationship drama without the relationships being mostly romance-focused.
I
love relationship drama. I eat it up with a spoon. People fighting and angsting over their fights and making up; people learning and growing and evolving their relationships over time; people discovering a fondness for someone they never looked at twice, or having longtime relationships blow up in their face. Basically I just like relationship drama a lot. :D
But problem #1 is, I'm not especially fond of romance -- or I guess I should say, I'm not fond of
the romance story, the one that's told in the vast majority of romance-focused media. (Boy meets girl; boy and girl fight; boy and girl struggle with their feelings for 60 episodes or so; boy and girl cave and admit they are Now Officially Together; the end.) There are MANY MANY other romantic stories that can be told, and I like many of them, but The Official Romance Story is boring to me, and even more, I hate the way that romance has a tendency to take over the other relationships on the show, either by sidelining them completely or by converting them into romances as well, because Romance Is The Most Important Thing and it's the story most writers want to tell.
(Which isn't bad, necessarily. It's just not for me.)
And problem #2 is that I tend to get bored and annoyed when relationship drama is the entire focus of the show. I want relationship drama ON A SPACESHIP or people having relationship drama WHILE FIGHTING CRIME!
And the thing about White Collar is that it's relationship-drama-focused in
exactly the same way as most romances -- in the sense that it's all about the relationship between these two people, it's always
going to be about them, and no matter how many times they break up, there is probably going to be a happy ending, after serving up bucketloads of angst first -- but it's
not a boy-meets-girl romance.
And let me tell you, as someone who seeks out those kinds of stories ... that's RARE! It's not like there isn't some of it around, but mostly you get a bait-and-switch, in which the first few episodes serve up a variety of interesting, non-traditionally-romantic relationships, but ultimately it ends up being about the romance after all, and everything else tends to get shuffled out of the spotlight, ends badly, or never really gets followed up on. (LOST, Fringe, I'm looking at you.) Or else you have a lot of shows in which the central relationship(s) are more or less static (see: most buddy cop shows -- and frequently
that is served up with a side order of misogyny and/or homophobia).
But at the same time, White Collar isn't myopically focused on the central relationship; it's an ensemble, and the ensemble get lots of screen time, and lots of storylines and relationship focus too. There are some romances -- which I mostly enjoy -- and there's also a fascinating constellation of very different relationships, most of which get at least
some screen time on a regular basis, all of which is taking place against a backdrop of action-focused FBI/con artist heist hijinks.
So basically: White Collar gives me LOADS of relationship drama, in a show that is also charming and adorable and generally pretty respectful with the treatment of its female characters. It's not going to win any awards and it's not ~great art~, but it's charming and sweet and funny and well put together, and probably heading for a happy ending after serving up enough angst along the way to keep the sweetness from being too cloying. It's static enough that I don't expect any major shakeups (killing off half the cast, say) but it's changeable enough that things
do evolve over time and the characters have ended up in a fairly different place than they started out.
Basically this show has absolutely
nailed my ideal-TV-comfort-food formula.