Hmm ... thoughts on Prodigal
Nov. 8th, 2008 11:09 pmOthers have squeed about SGA's The Prodigal, already. I appear to have gotten distracted with meta.
... specifically, this meta linked from the noticeboard (warning: spoilers for Prodigal and potential squee-harshing). I think that the post's author has a good point as regards writing in general (being true to the integrity of your characters) -- I just disagree strenuously over the specific example that s/he used from the episode, to the point where it makes me wonder if we're even watching the same show! Rather than responding with a comment, since I don't know how this person would feel about some random stranger jumping in with wildly divergent thoughts, I ended up soapboxing over here. (At quite a bit of length, too.)
( Raaaaaambling, with spoilers for Prodigal and quotes from the squee-harshing post in question )
... and, totally unrelated to the above, I just realized that the "Athosians are matriarchal" theory got another strong bit of support back in Search & Rescue -- babies take their mother's last names! I'm not sure if I can really give the writers credit for doing this on purpose; it may simply have happened by serendipitous accident because they were thinking in "Teyla as single mother" mode and/or had completely forgotten about Kanaan. But when she said her son's full name, his last name was Emmagan ...!
... specifically, this meta linked from the noticeboard (warning: spoilers for Prodigal and potential squee-harshing). I think that the post's author has a good point as regards writing in general (being true to the integrity of your characters) -- I just disagree strenuously over the specific example that s/he used from the episode, to the point where it makes me wonder if we're even watching the same show! Rather than responding with a comment, since I don't know how this person would feel about some random stranger jumping in with wildly divergent thoughts, I ended up soapboxing over here. (At quite a bit of length, too.)
( Raaaaaambling, with spoilers for Prodigal and quotes from the squee-harshing post in question )
... and, totally unrelated to the above, I just realized that the "Athosians are matriarchal" theory got another strong bit of support back in Search & Rescue -- babies take their mother's last names! I'm not sure if I can really give the writers credit for doing this on purpose; it may simply have happened by serendipitous accident because they were thinking in "Teyla as single mother" mode and/or had completely forgotten about Kanaan. But when she said her son's full name, his last name was Emmagan ...!