sholio: sun on winter trees (Default)
This is the sequel to the post-Cold-War spy thriller The Eighth Sister, which I reviewed here and enjoyed with caveats, but this book I flat-out loved. As I noted in the other review, the part of the previous book I liked best was when the characters were cat-and-mousing around Russia, and this book is nearly all that. In addition to that, this book features the return of my two favorite supporting characters from the previous book, one of whom was presumed dead (but isn't), and a sympathetic Russian agent who was chasing them before and is reluctantly helping them this time around, admittedly after being blackmailed into it.

The action scenes are flat-out fantastic - this book features, among other things, an escape from a high-security Russian prison, a really fun (if OTT and logistically implausible) con on the not!KGB, and a car/snowmobile/air chase through a blizzard in and around St. Petersburg that is an amazing sequence of endlessly piled-up complications and basically a demonstration of the writing principle of "take the worst thing that could happen to your character at this particular moment and then do that."

But what really makes both this and the previous book work for me is how likable the characters are. I love the tropes of spy fiction - the moral shades of gray, the ethical and human difficulties of coping with undercover work, the action sequences - but a lot of it is too bleak and not humanistic enough for me. I think a lot of what made the action scenes in this book so tense was how desperately you want all the characters to make it out alive. Even the minor characters in this and the preceding book are, on the whole, decent people (a family who smuggle refugees across the Black Sea, a random not!KGB dude who goes out of his way to do the right thing at a key moment even though it might cost him his career at the very least and his life at worst, etc). The protagonist is a guy who quit the spy game years ago and keeps getting sucked back in to help friends, and he doesn't particularly give a damn about the broader principles of patriotism or whatever is going on between his government and theirs; what he mainly wants is just to get home to his family.

I've been borrowing a lot of Kindle Unlimited books in the general category of thriller and detective mystery because I want to learn how to write it, and have bounced off a lot of it because it's simply too bleak, violent, politically conservative, and generally either too grimdark or draws the good-and-evil lines in the wrong places for me, so there was something very affirming about the discovery that you can, in fact, be successful in a very cynical genre with books that are actually very much about affirming human connection rather than tearing it down.

(On a side note, these books also might be the only Cold War-esque spy novels I've read with a black hero, which provides endless complications in trying to make himself inconspicuous in Russia...)

I don't think this book is a highly realistic depiction of what spying is actually like, but it was was a fun, exciting few hours with characters I really liked and totally snuck in as an under-the-wire Yuletide nomination, and I would absolutely read more books about them if the author ever writes any. I also hope that someday it gets optioned as a movie or a Netflix miniseries or something, because this book would be such fun in live action.
sholio: (Books)
So, moving on to Kindle Unlimited books I actually enjoyed ... I finished reading this one tonight - The Eighth Sister by Robert Dugoni. It's a fairly straightforward Cold War spy plot (someone is killing undercover agents; the hero needs to find out whodunnit without giving himself away) transplanted to the modern era.

Despite really enjoying some of the tropes, I don't read that widely in spy fiction; it's the sort of thing (much like steampunk and Westerns) where I like some of the trappings and tropes a great deal, but often find the actual execution offputting. However, I found the first chapter enough of a hook to keep going, and ended up enjoying the book a lot, for the most part (see caveat below). The main character is a likable guy, a retired CIA agent with a wife and family who gets reactivated for one last mission, and the book never slipped over into the rah-rah patriotism that is one reason why I don't tend to read a lot of this kind of book; in fact, it's much more Le Carré-ish in the sense that our government and their government are both pretty terrible, and the agents on the ground have more in common with each other than with the guys giving them their marching orders.

My one big caveat is that the pacing is just weird. The author is very good at writing tense, engrossing, detail-rich action scenes, but a little too committed (for my tastes, anyway) to the kind of realism that results in these tense, exciting action scenes coming to an anticlimactic end and then being followed by several chapters of the characters dealing with the realistic-but-dull political fallout.

My favorite part of the book by far was the middle third, which is a tense cat-and-mouse chase between the hero (assisted by a Russian double agent), and a pursuing Russian agent who is clever and resourceful and not really a bad guy. This unfortunately peters out with no particular sense of climax and is followed by an endless court case that utterly failed to engage me. Also, none of the book's questions are really answered; the plot pingpongs around between different setpieces which feel like they belong to several different books.

However, the next book in the series (not out yet) looks -- from the description, at least -- like it's going to focus on the aspects I loved best about this book, this time with this book's hero and the Russian agent from the previous book teaming up, and also might feature the return of a supposedly-dead supporting character from this book who I really liked and didn't want to lose. I plan to check it out, and wish it was out so I could read it now, because now I have a yearning for more like this.

Along those lines ... does anyone have recommendations for good spy thrillers? It's okay if it's dark and violent and ends badly; in this genre, I'm fine with that, as long as the journey is compelling enough to make it worth it. Authors/series I've read and enjoyed in the past: Le Carré, Charles McCarry, the Mrs. Pollifax books (which are really more spy cozies, but do have some of the tropes), and, believe it or not, the James Bond books, which have not aged well IN THE SLIGHTEST, but I read all of them in college and actually still have a few (and an enduring fondness for Felix Lieter, James Bond's lighter and friendlier American counterpart). Movie recommendations are welcome too.

Profile

sholio: sun on winter trees (Default)
Sholio

April 2025

S M T W T F S
   1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 2223242526
27282930   

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Apr. 23rd, 2025 02:11 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios