sholio: sun on winter trees (Default)
Sholio ([personal profile] sholio) wrote2009-03-29 09:17 pm
Entry tags:

The exodus approaches...

First, before I type anything else - I just realized that I never thanked the people who nominated me for Stargate fan awards. So ... THANK YOU, wonderful people! I'm so sorry it took me so long to say so! *bows in your general direction*

Anyway, moving on ... Dreamwidth (new fandom-friendly journaling platform) has announced their open beta dates (accounts will be available April 30).

[Poll #1374680]

I've been watching my f'list abuzz with this, and feeling ... mildly conflicted.

Since 1995, a significant amount of my social life has been online. In that time, I can think of three different online "places" off the top of my head (a mailing list, a message board, and LJ) that I've thought of as "home" at the time. In all three cases, I spent years there, made enduring friendships and business contacts, shared major developments in my life ... and (except for LJ, yet) eventually moved on, as the group splintered and scattered.

I've also participated in, and sometimes run, dozens of mailing lists, message boards and blogs; I've had at least a half-dozen different message boards and blogs on my own webspace (none of which really took off, though some were pretty active for a short while).

So the thought never occurred to me that LJ would be permanent, any more than I expect the house I live in now to be the house I live in until I die. At the same time, though, I don't particularly want to move. I'm comfy, I have everything set up the way I like it, and most of my currently active online social circle is here. But I can feel the winds of change blowing; whether I stay or go or straddle both sites, I suspect that fandom (at least the corner of fandom where I "live") is about to split and reshape itself again. I've certainly been around long enough to know that this is normal and inevitable; fandom changes and reshapes all the time. I was kinda behind the curve on LJ fandom; I didn't really get active here until it was already going full-bore, so there was a (deceptive) sense of permanence to LJ fandom for me -- in Internet terms, it was ancient and rock-solid when I first jumped in, not to mention that I got in on the new, hot fandom (SGA) while it was on a popularity upswing. Compared to the Internet at large, it seemed monumentally stable and permanent. There were very few dead links, and lots of lively, active journals and discussions -- it felt like you could link to a story on an LJ journal and expect to still be there several years later, which is a sort of permanence that didn't really exist back in the days of personal Geocities homepages and mailing list archives.

Now I'm starting to notice growing numbers of blogs that are struckthrough in older comment threads; dead links leading to posts that have been privatized and journals that no longer exist; communities with tons of posts in their archives but not much activity now. I don't really get the feeling that LJ fandom is winding down, exactly, but it's starting to feel ... impermanent, in a way that it didn't before.

So ... I'm conflicted. Right now I'm leaning towards some combination of "maintain a Dreamwidth journal for reading purposes" and "let's see where fandom goes". I'm pretty much in it for the social life; all I really want is a journaling platform that'll basically leave me alone to do my thing -- and I know that LJ isn't perfect, but my own experiences with it have been good, despite some of the stories I've heard. I don't mind leaving -- like I said, I'm not wedded to the place -- but I'm in no great hurry to leave, either. I basically just want to be where the interesting discussions and the people I care about can be found.
ext_21:   (Default)

[identity profile] zvi-likes-tv.livejournal.com 2009-03-31 03:01 pm (UTC)(link)
Sorry, sorry. I don't mean to turn into an obnoxious evangelist who just can't let people dislike her One True Way. I just don't want someone who is trying to backhop their way around to an understanding of what Dreamwidth is to come across misinformation and decide to not look it over because, for instance, they're not in fandom.
ext_1981: (Default)

[identity profile] friendshipper.livejournal.com 2009-03-31 05:27 pm (UTC)(link)
FWIW, I really do appreciate you (and Rydra) coming in and correcting misinformation or wrong assumptions on Dreamwidth -- I'm only tangentially watching it, so I don't know/don't notice a lot of this. :)