sholio: Zemo in fur-collared coat (Avengers-Zemo3)
Sholio ([personal profile] sholio) wrote2021-11-17 10:32 pm

In today's Zemo thoughts

By way of a gifset showing off Daniel Bruhl's puppy eyes in one particular Civil War scene (the rational part of my brain: let's not forget there's a dead body in the bathtub throughout this scene, however) I ended up rewatching the Zemo scenes in Civil War tonight, as you do ...

(How is this my life now.)

... and thinking about something that [personal profile] sheron and I were talking about recently, which is that while he is absolutely ruthless about his goals, and there are certain categories of people that he seems to kill without remorse (supersoldiers, Hydra, people who are actively trying to kill him), he actually seems to try to go out of his way not to kill, hurt, or even attack most people if he doesn't have to. This is underscored much more heavily than I remembered in his establishing scene with the Hydra guy:

Zemo: Hydra deserves its place on the ash heap, so your death would not bother me. But I'd have to use this book, and other, bloodier methods to find what I need. I don't look forward to that.

It's really interesting to me that they went with this method of introducing him, where it's true that his introduction is ruthless and brutal, but also he appears to be trying to avoid what he considers unnecessary bloodshed or collateral damage, and the plot of the movie is actually his backup plan when the first one doesn't pan out. At the end of that scene, if anything, he looks resigned and unhappy - as he said, he doesn't mind killing the Hydra guy, but he really didn't want to have to do the rest of it.

(There's a deleted scene with an alternate method of Zemo acquiring the book, which appears to involve Zemo killing a room full of people - possibly only knocking them out, but that really didn't look gentle. Anyway, it's one of those narrative decisions where it turns his arc into something very different than if gassing a room full of people and then moving on to terrorism was actually his plan A.)

On the other hand, this rewatch impressed on me all over again how absolutely batshit his Plan B is.

Presumably his original plan - while obsessive, ruthless, and not how we handle emotional trauma, Zemo - was relatively straightforward, with a minimum of collateral damage aside from wrecking the lives of a handful of people he blames for his family's deaths: Interrogate the Hydra guy for the information he needed, fly to Siberia and kill the other Winter Soldiers and get the video, and then, idk, perhaps mail the video to Tony and off himself in Siberia.

But no, that didn't work!

Then he had to go to plan B, which was more like:



"Step 49 of 1107: create a realistic Bucky face mask."

(I mean, it's in character, but also, why are you so extra, Zemo.)

Anyway, I really like how consistent the CW part of his character development actually is with the TFATWS part, allowing for the fact that he's obviously unhinged with grief in 2016 and by the Falcon & Winter Soldier time period, has had some time to deal with it and develop a new Reason For Living (at least 50% less unhinged, though still kinda fanatic).
sovay: (Renfield)

[personal profile] sovay 2021-11-18 09:25 am (UTC)(link)
On the other hand, this rewatch impressed on me all over again how absolutely batshit his Plan B is.

And contains a spectacular failure mode, which is: whoops, assassinated the king of Wakanda! One shudders to imagine his Plan C.
Edited 2021-11-18 09:33 (UTC)
muccamukk: Wanda walking away, surrounded by towering black trees, her red cloak bright. (Default)

[personal profile] muccamukk 2021-11-18 12:12 pm (UTC)(link)
That all of CA:CW hinged on Zemo's completely bonkers plan B was one of my main objections to it at the time, along with how many people had to have idiot balls tied to their ankles to make his Plan B work. (It should not have worked!)
silverflight8: bee on rose  (Default)

[personal profile] silverflight8 2021-11-18 02:42 pm (UTC)(link)
Right, Zemo wasn't just going to bomb the UN and leave some Winter Soldier evidence behind (now struggling to think of what exactly - a flash of the arm? Clothing is probably not identifiable) so he went out and made prostheses for the face and left them behind on purpose for them to find. Lmao.

Also that gifset is 🥰 the eyes!
scioscribe: (mcu: gamora)

[personal profile] scioscribe 2021-11-18 04:09 pm (UTC)(link)
This is a very great and useful meta for characterization purposes. *bookmarks* I really love trying to work out characters' moral priorities, for lack of a better term, and it feels especially relevant with him, Sam, and Bucky and the idea of the three of them working together.

"Step 49 of 1107: create a realistic Bucky face mask."

(I mean, it's in character, but also, why are you so extra, Zemo.)


Okay, now I need there to be a running fandom joke where they're in some desperate situation and Zemo's like, "I can get us out of this, but I'm going to need the following ridiculously specific items/skills," e.g., "I can break us out of prison, but first I'm going to need several tubes of theatrical greasepaint and a high-quality sound recording of a train, and you're going to have to learn some conversational Polish."
sovay: (Renfield)

[personal profile] sovay 2021-11-18 07:07 pm (UTC)(link)
e.g., "I can break us out of prison, but first I'm going to need several tubes of theatrical greasepaint and a high-quality sound recording of a train, and you're going to have to learn some conversational Polish."

At no point during the prison break do Sam and Bucky end up needing to speak Polish; they never find out if that was part of the contingency plan or Zemo trolling. When asked point-blank sometime after the fact, he just does the head-tilt.
sheron: RAF bi-plane doodle (Johns) (Default)

[personal profile] sheron 2021-11-19 12:51 am (UTC)(link)
When asked point-blank sometime after the fact, he just does the head-tilt.

LOL!
scioscribe: (mcu: gamora)

[personal profile] scioscribe 2021-11-19 01:17 am (UTC)(link)
Yes, I support this.
sovay: (Renfield)

[personal profile] sovay 2021-11-19 08:56 pm (UTC)(link)
but I'm not sure if I've seen anyone lean into the movie details that he's very good at cryptography, data analysis, and (apparently) building EMP bombs from scratch.

Please do: I agree with you. I feel like people remember the intelligence work when it comes to head games, but not the professional rest of it.
sheron: black coffee (black coffee)

[personal profile] sheron 2021-11-19 12:53 am (UTC)(link)
I will never stop finding it hilarious that I found Zemo interesting as a villain even back in the CA:CW times :D He was just so intense about it. Granted, I didn't realize my future held quite so much Zemo in it :D