sholio: slice of pie with ice cream and apples (Autumn-apple pie)
Sholio ([personal profile] sholio) wrote2012-05-02 12:13 pm

100 Things #2

Since I'm procrastinating anyway, I may as well do two of them at once. *g*

100 Things: 100 favorite scenes from anything (books, movies, TV, fanfic, etc) #2

This one is from a series of books that almost nobody on my flist has read except for me. *cough* But I know at least a few of you have! I first read them 15 years ago, somewhat unexpectedly recommended to me by a male friend (unexpected due to the fact that the h/c quotient in these books is so far through the roof that even fanfic barely touches the level of some of it).

The series in question is Margaret Weis & Tracy Hickman's Death Gate Cycle.

And the scene in question

**MAJOR SPOILERS HERE**

is the aftermath of Haplo's death in Book 7, Serpent Mage, when you finally catch onto the dog's function as the other half of Haplo's soul.

... admittedly I think it's apparent quite a ways before then (like, all the way in book 1) that there is something hinky about the dog and it has to do with Haplo, but I don't recall really GETTING it until the dog shows up after Haplo's death, and Alfred reacts the way that he does. And then there was that delightful penny-dropping "...ohhh!" moment, all the better because it was an AWESOME get-out-of-death-free card, the groundwork having been laid from the very first book.

I suppose there is no way to be 100% certain whether the authors had that particular fate for the dog in mind from the beginning -- there are definitely aspects of the books that make me think quite a lot of the series was unplotted, seat-of-the-pants improvising *g* -- but there is enough consistency to the dog's behavior and its relationship with Haplo that I suspect its basic nature was, indeed, part of the plan all along.

And I do love a good death fake-out. As I'm sure will become obvious as I go through the rest of these. *g*

(I must admit that for sheer h/c value, the healing scene in Fire Sea is head and shoulders above this one -- and since I have 100 of these to go through, it'll probably get its own entry eventually -- but I think this one beats it out because, seriously, seven books of setup.)
torachan: (Default)

[personal profile] torachan 2012-05-03 05:57 am (UTC)(link)
I loved these books when I read them (I think Death Gate is my favorite Weiss & Hickman work, including Dragonlance), but I cannot for the life of me remember a single thing about them now. XD (I would say maybe I should reread them, but I am a lot less tolerant of bad writing now than I was as a teenager, so I am always afraid to reread old favorites lest I find out they're actually horrible.)
torachan: (Default)

[personal profile] torachan 2012-05-03 06:56 am (UTC)(link)
Yeah, I suspect there is a lot of problematic stuff in books I remember fondly, so it's best to just keep the fond memories!
bossymarmalade: sign for truvy's beauty spot (it's amy tyre's moment to shine)

[personal profile] bossymarmalade 2012-05-03 10:11 pm (UTC)(link)
I agree heartily with you both -- I recently-ish reread, uh, Elven Star? Or whatever book it was where the two human siblings and two elf siblings got trapped on that vine world with the titans who were looking for The Citadel. And it was ... not good. Fond memories of Haplo and Dog in the Labyrinth are much better than rereading, heh.