sholio: sun on winter trees (Sheppard-leafgold)
Sholio ([personal profile] sholio) wrote2008-10-29 11:26 pm
Entry tags:

Due South season one (most of it)

So, we're watching Due South, slowly but surely -- well, re-watching, in my case. We really don't watch much TV in general, aside from the handful of shows that we follow week to week; something has to really catch our eye in order to want to binge on it. So far, DS is a show that we can watch in little dribs and drabs, here and there, when we want to kick back with an episode or two.

We've watched up to the end of the Victoria's Secret 2-parter -- and yes, I know what you're thinking, but I watched it back in its original run on TV, so I'm not particularly bothered by the cliffhanger since I know how it ends, and hubby doesn't get into the emotional arcs the way that I do. I do remember how shriek-inducing that cliffhanger was when I watched it as an h/c-loving teenager, though...

It's actually quite fascinating, watching a show that I first saw when I was in a very different place, literally and emotionally. Back then, I only saw the first season or two; I do know what happens later, casting-wise -- you'd have to be living under a fan-rock not to -- but I think I only saw an episode or two from that part of the series, so it'll all be new to me when I get there. But, from the earlier part of the series, I vaguely remember a lot of the episodes, and a number of individual scenes in the episodes, but I'm seeing them through a different lens now, so to speak.

One of the big surprises is that I remember this show being really frustrating to me on a visceral, h/c/friendship level. I remember feeling like it teased but didn't deliver what I wanted out of it, emotionally. Which made me realize how much more attuned to nuance I am now than I was at 17, because wow, does it ever deliver! I'm really finding it just about perfect, actually -- too much overt emotion makes me squirmy (see: Supernatural), not enough leaves me emotionally flat. DS walks the middle line in a way I really like. Both Fraser and Ray are obviously important to the other, the friendship itself is important to them, but they've got individual lives, individual pasts. They're not joined at the hip. In fact, I really don't think they know each other very well. But they know what counts: they've got each other's back. I don't think this is a show that I could read slash for, at least not with Vecchio; besides just not seeing it, the loss of that individual autonomy would, I think, take away a lot of what I like about the show. They care about each other deeply as friends, but they don't need each other. I really like that.

I've also been skimming [livejournal.com profile] truepenny's Due South reviews -- not reading every single one (I don't think I'm into the show that much) but browsing one here and there. And I came across something that really clicked with me, as far as how I relate to the characters, and why I like the characters I do, in the way that I do. From her review of "The Man Who Knew Too Little:

Ray's causes are different, personal. Fraser will sacrifice himself for an abstraction; for Ray it's about the people he loves.

I've always got the impression, looking in on DS fandom from the outside, that most DS fans are first and foremost Fraser fans -- this may be entirely wrong, but it's the impression I've received. I'm not; I never have been. And this, I think, is why. I like Fraser, but I don't love him; I don't always like Ray, but I love him utterly. Kind of like how I relate to Rodney -- I don't like some of the things he does, and I try to remember when I write him that he's quite often an unlikable person, but I find him impossible not to love. Ray, like Rodney, is not always nice, but he's fundamentally a good person. Fraser ... he's always nice, even in the most desperate situations, but I'm not entirely convinced he's good. Or maybe, like Carrot from the Ankh-Morpork books, he's too good. Fraser would never lie to you or insult you ... but he would use you, in the very nicest possible way. And I'm really afraid to think how far he'd go in pursuit of his ideals -- what he'd be willing to sacrifice. He might hate himself for doing it, but he'd do it. Even in "Victoria's Secret", when he basically has to choose between duty and love, and chooses love -- the way that he does it is, in its own way, as scary and obsessive as the way he pursues duty. It's like he doesn't know how to be any other way, and if he doesn't have the one force driving him, he has to substitute another in its place. His black and white value system might have shifted a little, but it's no less black and white.

I find it very difficult to relate to characters whose value system is based in abstracts. Petty, emotional motivations (jealousy and friendship, love and fear) are much easier for me to understand and sympathize with than grand ideals like justice and upholding the law -- the latter are far more interesting to me in the breach, where, say, the character's desire for justice comes into conflict with friendship or love, and love wins. I've been reading superhero comics for a long time, but it's not the paragons that I sympathize with; it's the second bananas and sidekicks and, occasionally, the villains. Fraser, in a lot of ways, reminds me of the superheroes that I find likable but remote. He's larger than life, hypercompetent to the point of absurdity; he's not quite a superhero and not quite a running joke, but at times, he's both. We see enough of his doubts and fears on the show to know that he has them, that he's human. But even after a season, I don't think I understand him well enough to write him at all. I sympathize instantly and automatically with Ray, where with Fraser I just don't -- he's more easily admired from arm's length.

[identity profile] nebbyjen.livejournal.com 2008-10-30 10:44 am (UTC)(link)
I wasn't a faithful viewer when the show first aired but a few years ago I did purchase Seasons 1 and 2. Original Ray was my favorite and like you said in your review, he reminds me of McKay (without the whole genius thing). DS was easy to watch, the growing friendship between Fraser and Ray usually left me smiling. If you'd like to borrow Season 2 let me know.

[identity profile] wraithfodder.livejournal.com 2008-10-30 12:07 pm (UTC)(link)
got a question totally not about the show but the disks. can i ask which version you bought? Platinum or ??? I just got the 'entire series in one' dvd set and I don't think the transfer quality is all that hot, and it is Platinum, at least it says so.

[identity profile] nebbyjen.livejournal.com 2008-10-30 01:49 pm (UTC)(link)
Platinum. Not super crisp/clear but still nice. Of course I had to pop a disc in to check and well....you know.... now I'm on disc 2. Thank goodness I have to go to work or I'd watch all of them again and totally blow the day.

[identity profile] wraithfodder.livejournal.com 2008-10-31 12:57 am (UTC)(link)
Ah, okay. Yeah, Due South is an 'oldie' so, won't be as crystal clear as say a brand new show :) Thanks!

memory lane

[identity profile] jimandblair.livejournal.com 2008-10-30 01:14 pm (UTC)(link)
this is probably going to be a tad incoherent, because it's all wrapped up in long forgotten emotions *g*. I adored due South;, it was my first internet fandom (i.e. you suddenly found the mother load) after scuttling in the wainscoting as a baby Trek fan, Pro and Dr. Who fan. I knew that there had to be people out there (in the universe) who also really enjoyed telly but where the fuck were they? I was squealing over an ep and saw a 'www.duesouth.com' thingy and my mate Robin took me to the Uni computer lab and showed me this thing called The Internet. HAH!

Due South was where I realised to write fanfic effectively I needed to like more than one protagonist. The mismatch of the characters: perfect, aloof, emotionally naive and (in my fics) emotionally abused Fraser versus volatile, complex, driven Vecchio was just the perfect recipe. And then the series kept throwing all these extra ingredients into the pot. Fraser wasn't as emotionally naive as I thought, he was repressed.

It was a series where I knew intellectually I was missing a lot of the subtlety and the in-jokes, but enjoyed it nevertheless. Ultimately the undercurrent that Paul Gross and David Marciano weren't that fond of each other turned me off it and then when Vecchio was replaced by RayII, I bailed. The emotional investment on my side was far too high for a telly programme *g*. It was exhausting. It would be interesting to re-watch the episodes

Re: memory lane

[identity profile] jimandblair.livejournal.com 2008-10-30 05:29 pm (UTC)(link)
Scuttling in the wainscoting ... ahahahaha, awesome image!

I knew that there had to be like minded people out there, but... geez... where??. The internets is pretty great. But I have to admit it would be pretty cool to have a mate living locally who I could hook up with for a good crack about fandom face-to-face.

It sounds like we were watching about the same time agewise. I carted my little portable telly off to Uuni with an old VCR. I was not going to go without my fix of SF. I remember contemplating a week of baked beans on toast versus buying a VHS tape of the BSDM episode of due South which was not going to be televised on the BBC -- and buying the tape \o/

character friction has always been one of the main ingredients for me to love a show.
I'm not massively fond of friction. I've rarely re-watched Trinity. Fairy Tales, FTW

I read ezazahaz comment -- it interesting in that back when due South was on I loved Fraser's strict adherence to a moral framework whereas if I was to write due South now it would be more about investigating dichotomy between the characters’ moral outlooks. I guess that's just age talking.

You should stay with it, even due to the Vechhio stuff – there’s a fair number of fans out there who really, really warmed to Calum Keith Rennie’s character. I didn’t but that’s just me.

Re: memory lane

[identity profile] jimandblair.livejournal.com 2008-10-30 06:11 pm (UTC)(link)
*snigger* when I read 'Western fandom' I thought SGA ≠ horses + wild west +s(gunfights) 0_o

yes, it was 1996/1997 when I discovered the resource which is

\o/ = fanfic^10 = fandom + internets

[identity profile] ezazahaz.livejournal.com 2008-10-30 03:52 pm (UTC)(link)
Re: your last two paragraphs
I am in 100% agreement with you. I love DS, but Fraser has just never done it for me. It's hard for me to care about a character who would sacrifice himself for a complete stranger as easily as for a loved one. I need someone to *show* that they care for someone or a few someones more than The Entire World. Some shows and movies even turn me off because they're far too focused on this abstract "Save everyone" and not enough on the friendship and love of a few people.

It reminds me of a quote from another old show, actually:
"There are two kinds of people in this life my friend. There are those who seek battle and seem not to fear death; like them. Then there are those who avoid battle, but will stand and fight to the death if their loved ones are threatened; like them. That is true courage."

IMHO, Ray and Rodney have true courage. Fraser would die to protect the honor of a box of cornflakes. Good for him, but it's the other characters I'm going to love.
Edited 2008-10-30 15:53 (UTC)

[identity profile] tipper-green.livejournal.com 2008-10-30 08:50 pm (UTC)(link)
Oooh, this is interesting: Due South does this a little bit, but mostly in an oblique way (the way that he presumes on Ray's friendship, for example). I think, that if I had any one complaint about Fraser, that would be it. That he presumes on Ray's friendship. It used to sort of annoy me how Ray would seem to make this effort all the time, he'd "be there", so to speak, but Fraser wouldn't give back. Victoria is one of those eps that pained me a little, for that reason.

It's funny. For some reason, I'm reminded of another show where I was more fond of the "best friend" than the hero, and that was Evening Edition (At least, I think that's what it was called). I mean, I loved both the hero and the best friend, but I leaned towards the best friend there too, even though he was something of a slimeball at time. Maybe because he was a slimeball, but he'd still end up risking his life for his friend in the end. (Then he became painful comic relief...but before that, he was fun)

[identity profile] tipper-green.livejournal.com 2008-10-30 05:45 pm (UTC)(link)
Now you make me want to go back and watch it again! Ray V. was also the heart of that show for me, which, considering that, other than fabulous green eyes (I'm a total sucker for really green eyes), he's not much to look at. Yet, I totally and completely loved him. I never really wondered why, but now I want to know. I definitely think you've come up with a really good reason--that Ray is more about the emotional than the abstract. If I go down my list of "favorites" in my head, most of them have that characteristic. I do think you see it more in the "best friend" character than the lead, which is why I tend to favor the best friend character over the lead, but there are exceptions (Mal from Firefly being an obvious one). I always lean towards the darker, pettier character who redeems himself over that of the do no wrong character. It's why both John and Rodney work for me, whereas Elizabeth rarely did. Or why I favored Rimmer in Red Dwarf. Even the Doctor is often more concerned with himself and his companion than the universe at large, which is what makes him such a fun character to follow.

But back to Due South...man, I loved that show. And, I'll tell you, the episode that always comes first in my mind is the one where they're traipsing through Canada, with Ray carrying Fraser, Ray bitching and moaning the whole time (but, of course, *never* leaving Fraser behind). I've used it a hundred different ways in fanfiction, because it had such an impact. I haven't seen it in a dozen years or more, but it's sort of a standard for me: the ideal that newer shows need to live up to. I don't have high expectations, do I?

(Oh, the quote up above? That's Ezra from Mag 7 the Series. The show itself never lived up to its potential, but Ezra was a great, great character...)

(Anonymous) 2008-10-30 07:15 pm (UTC)(link)
(Nah - M7 is not old at all. 1997-1998 was its run, I think. BUT, this quote is very possibly a revised version of an older quote)

[identity profile] jimandblair.livejournal.com 2008-10-30 06:19 pm (UTC)(link)
due South provided the best hurt/comfort. It's been my yardstick for yonks... "Letting Go" and "North" were 45 mins of pure h/c gold.

[identity profile] dovil.livejournal.com 2008-10-30 08:17 pm (UTC)(link)
What a fabulous write up.

I just recently glutted myself on DS for the first time and was really taken (by the first two seasons in particular) - it ambled along and it was puppy cute and the most adorable thing ever and then would just side swipe you with gravitas and, as you say, emotional resonance that wasn't the constant lip trembling and tear dripping of Supernatural, and felt like more of a punch to the system because of it.

[identity profile] snarkydame.livejournal.com 2008-10-30 11:31 pm (UTC)(link)
I just went through my second spree of Due South viewing. [personal profile] truepenny's episode reviews inspired me to watch a show I'd previously dismissed as amusing but shallow with a more critical eye -- and I enjoyed it very much this time around!

And despite the horrid Ray V versus Ray K wars in the fandom, I think they're both worth watching, and I think Frasier's reactions to both of them are really interesting.

Have fun with the show!

[identity profile] snarkydame.livejournal.com 2008-10-31 03:44 pm (UTC)(link)
[personal profile] pentapus made it. *g*

And while there are some fantastic fic and vids in the fandom, most of the focus seems to be slash (which is fine, but I do like me some good gen sometimes, yeah?).

[identity profile] tringasolitaria.livejournal.com 2008-10-30 11:35 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh very cool - DueSouth thoughts. Do you mind if I link to this? I have some flist members who I think might be interested.

I confess I am one of those Fraser fans primarily - there's something about his emotional brokenness and repression that gets to me. It feels to me like he hides behind the rules and the concepts because, well, if that all falls away, he doesn't have anything else. But I do like Ray Vecchio very much, and Ray Kowalski (I think I'm one of the few who likes them both). They each brought a different dynamic to the show, and I enjoyed both.

I couldn't actually see slashing Vecchio and Fraser either - theirs was much more of a best friends/buddies type relationship. I can see where all the Fraser/RayK slash comes from, but maybe that's just because of reading about Paul Gross's comment that he and Callum Keith Rennie did play up the subtext there.

Thanks for the link to truepenny's reviews - I enjoyed reading them. :)
aelfgyfu_mead: Due South: Fraser, original Ray, Diefenbaker (Due South)

[personal profile] aelfgyfu_mead 2008-10-31 12:45 am (UTC)(link)
because wow, does it ever deliver! I'm really finding it just about perfect, actually
Yes! YES! I didn't see it during its original run; I saw it just over eight years ago, and I adore Fraser and Ray. (I never did get into Ray K.; we haven't seen all of that final season, but now we have them on DVD and will when we have time, if that ever happens.)

I can relate to Fraser--maybe because he's scary and obsessive. I fear that's what I would be without Brilliant Husband to balance me out.

I love David Marciano and I'm sad that he never got another good role like this.

Paul Gross is far more likeable as Geoffrey Tennant in Slings and Arrows, I think, but Fraser's interactions with Ray, and with his Dad, and with Dief!, made me love him too.

I don't often get to use this icon!
aelfgyfu_mead: Due South: Fraser, original Ray, Diefenbaker (Due South)

[personal profile] aelfgyfu_mead 2008-11-01 12:59 am (UTC)(link)
Actually, I just looked up David on IMDb, and it seems he's had a long run on The Shield! I have no interest in that show, which is kind of too bad, because I would like to see David again. It's good to see that he's working again, though, or at least has been recently!

[identity profile] with-apostrophe.livejournal.com 2008-11-01 07:22 am (UTC)(link)
I love Mr Marciano too. How could you not like a guy with a smile like the one in my icon.

Part of the reason that Ray V disappeared was because David was doing other work. But yes, it's sad he's not done more high profile stuff, because I always found him highly entertaining. Not only entertaining though - yes, he had the humour beats down pat, but he could also bring the tragedy and the sadder notes too.

[identity profile] sg-lab.livejournal.com 2008-10-31 11:11 pm (UTC)(link)
I found your post through [livejournal.com profile] tringasolitaria. I feel the same way about Ray V. I love him. I could go on for hours about him. :D

Daniel Jackson from SG-1 is a character I find is a lot like Fraser. They're both very willing to sacrifice for the abstract. And Jack O'Neill is like Ray who is willing to sacrifice for only the personal. And I tend to connect with the Ray's and the Jack's. The Daniel's and Frasers tend to leave me cold. They're interesting characters, but I don't love them and connect with them the same way.

And I hadn't thought about it, but what you mention about Rodney and Ray being similar I can definitely see that. I once read a piece of meta a few years ago comparing Rodney and Daniel. I don't remember why it was those two, but it talked about how Rodney is the kind of person to sacrifice for the more personal while Daniel was more abstract.

Ray K. was okay, but he just didn't do it for me.

Anyway, I'm glad I found this. While I have never been very involved in the DS fandom beyond reading fanfic, I too feel like there's so much love for Fraser, but not much for Ray V. And the Fraser/Kawalsky slash has taken over in the fanfic.

[identity profile] with-apostrophe.livejournal.com 2008-11-01 07:36 am (UTC)(link)
I should probably dig out my DS DVDs. I bought s1 in Canada (ha!) 2 years ago, and don't think I made it all the way through watching them. I adore the characters, but the 5-10mins of chasing the bad guy in each episode bores me.

I first watched DS in re-runs, not too long after they aired, on the good old BBC. At first I was a Fraser fan because he was the obvious good looking hero, but slowly I found myself liking Ray V.

Your comparison of Ray and Rodney is interesting, because Fraser and Sheppard share some commonalities too. Both are content with being loners but still manage to attract friends, both will go to extremes to do what they think is right, both repress their emotions, both "never see it coming".... OK the similarities stop there, but I think the fact that Ray V doesn't have that emotional repression contributes a great deal to why I switched over to him. Both Ray and John make me want to shake sense or SOMETHING into them, but I still love 'em!

[identity profile] ticiathethief.livejournal.com 2008-11-01 07:38 pm (UTC)(link)
*Points to icon and flaps hands.*

He is so dang cute.

*dies*

[identity profile] with-apostrophe.livejournal.com 2008-11-01 08:26 pm (UTC)(link)
I had a similar reaction when I first saw the photo.

That *SMILE*. Stunning.

[identity profile] with-apostrophe.livejournal.com 2008-11-02 07:27 am (UTC)(link)
Hhehe! The interesting thing is that the 2 parter with the Canadian 16 year old and the matchbook with the list has both one of the best plot motifs in it (watching the matchbook take its journey and come full circle) and one of the worst examples of conveying the passage of time that I've ever seen.

I watched the episode where Fraser is hurt so badly he's in hospital, but is still determined to help save his friend (Leslie Nielsen), so gets out of bed and follows on, ending up in a fight. THAT was very John Sheppard.

No, they don't map onto each other, and neither do Rodney and Ray, but there are characteristics they have in common, and John has more in common with Fraser and Rodney with Ray, than John and Ray and Rodney and Fraser.

[identity profile] with-apostrophe.livejournal.com 2008-11-02 02:43 pm (UTC)(link)
Erm. Ok?

I'm not too sure where this is going.

I observed that there were similarities. The example I gave pinged very strongly for me. That's it.

[identity profile] ticiathethief.livejournal.com 2008-11-01 07:37 pm (UTC)(link)
Completely and totally agree with everything you say.

I am definitely a Ray Vecchio fan. He was just so awesome. Benny? Eh, he was ok, but I could relate more to Ray.

The cliffie at the end of Victoria's secret? Eh, not that interested. But, the end of the NEXT episode, "Letting Go"? O.M.G. My teenage self squeed and freaked out. Heh