To be honest though as I said before if you're rec'ing a fic, it means it was good, I doubt there would be much would have an issue with.
This is a big assumption on my part, but I'd say that %99 of the rec's anyone makes the material of the story probably doesn't have enough 'negative' crit to even worth mentioning.
If I read an average 30 rec'd stories a month, I think almost 29-30 don't have anything glaring..kind makes the balanced rec kind of null and void. My example above was of an extreme, happened a few months ago....and was an on F-list LJ not a public listing.
This all falls down almsot to FB in a way, no need to 'look for crit' just give your overall take on something. In the end I think how you've been recing has been fine as I haven't come across anything that would make me think "oh why did she rec this it it had all this XYZ issues?"
I'll stand by if its worth recing, I doubt there was much to be critical to begin with.
Though I'm glad when I'm warned if something is dark or has chracter death.
no subject
This is a big assumption on my part, but I'd say that %99 of the rec's anyone makes the material of the story probably doesn't have enough 'negative' crit to even worth mentioning.
If I read an average 30 rec'd stories a month, I think almost 29-30 don't have anything glaring..kind makes the balanced rec kind of null and void. My example above was of an extreme, happened a few months ago....and was an on F-list LJ not a public listing.
This all falls down almsot to FB in a way, no need to 'look for crit' just give your overall take on something. In the end I think how you've been recing has been fine as I haven't come across anything that would make me think "oh why did she rec this it it had all this XYZ issues?"
I'll stand by if its worth recing, I doubt there was much to be critical to begin with.
Though I'm glad when I'm warned if something is dark or has chracter death.