Yeah ... I can see your points. It's such a tough call for me to make -- I don't want to predispose a reader not to like a story, because usually, when I'm reccing something, it's because I'm all "Squee! Yay!" about the story and I would like other people to have a chance for Squee! Yay! of their own. On the other hand, especially after reading some of the other comments here, I wonder if people might be MORE likely to give a story a chance if the flaws are mentioned in context, so they don't stop reading immediately when they hit a grammar error or misspelled name. Hmm...